Marvel: Get a clue about Japan!

Altared States

Buddha in a castle?!I've saved my favorite for last. In the first panel of this scene from Wolverine 171 (February 2002; Writer: Frank Tieri, Artist: Sean Chen), framed by those ever-blossoming cherry trees, we see a building that anyone even slightly familiar with Japanese architecture should recognize as a castle.

Never mind that any castles that exist in Japan nowadays are museums, and most of them are recent reconstructions of the originals. This one turns out to have a huge Buddha in it. A Buddha in a castle?

Since this is a "nuff said!" issue (one month during which nearly all Marvel comics were without Tieri's instructionsdialog), we can see Tieri's instructions to Chen in the back of the book, and lo and behold, Tieri asked Chen to draw a temple! THIS IS NOT A TEMPLE! And even if it were, you'd never see a Japanese temple with a Buddha statue sitting out in the middle of an empty room; it would be behind an altar, surrounded by a lot of other Buddhist artifacts, completely out of reach of the public, who would normally just throw some coins in the bin and briefly bow, not kneel. Anyway, religion is hardly a driving force in modern Japanese society; you'd have trouble finding a less religious country. But the people who do worship a god do not do so in castles!

 

In the January 2003 issue of Writers Digest, author Ridley Pearson wrote, "Remember: if you're writing about airplanes, chances are pilots will read it. If you're writing about rock music, chances are a rock musician will read it. People will know if you've done your homework or not."

Marvel artists and writers: before you do any more Japan stories, it's time to hit the books.

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

This site created by timyoungonline.com
This page last updated February 18, 2003 . E-mail Tim